- Industry
- 2 min read
Jayalalithaa death probe: Madras high court refuses to interfere with Justice Arumgasamy Commission proceedings
The Madras high court on Thursday refused to interfere in the probe conducted by the Justice A Arumughaswamy Commission into the causes that led to the death of former Tamil Nadu chief minister J Jayalalithaa.
A division bench of Justice R Subbiah and Justice Krishnan Ramasamy also rejected Apollo Hospitals’ plea to constitute a 21-member medical team to go into the correctness of treatment provided to Jayalalithaa.
The court said it was refraining from interfering in the proceedings since 90% of the inquiry was over.
"Since the commission had cast certain aspersions against the hospital, in our opinion, that by itself will not vitiate the inquiry proceedings hitherto. We hope and trust that the commission will confine his inquiry strictly within the scope and ambit of terms of reference made by the government. Further, it cannot also be said that the remarks made by the commission will form part of the final report to be submitted to the government," the bench said.
In its petition, Apollo Hospitals contended that Jayalalithaa had been treated by a medical team consisting of highly qualified and specialist doctors who had provided optimal and effective treatment. At no point of time either during her hospitalisation or immediately after the death, any concerns had been raised regarding the efficacy or appropriateness of treatment provided to her, the hospital said.
"In fact, the line of treatment was consistently validated by doctors from All India Institute of Medical Sciences and other external specialists. However, the state government ended up constituting a commission of inquiry about nine months after her death," it added
continued below
Opposing the pleas, the commission and the state government contended that the commission had powers to probe into the correctness of the treatment given to Jayalalithaa as per the terms of reference.
The commission further submitted that the hospital is free to challenge the final report of the commission after it is released, but not the proceedings.
COMMENTS
All Comments
By commenting, you agree to the Prohibited Content Policy
PostBy commenting, you agree to the Prohibited Content Policy
PostFind this Comment Offensive?
Choose your reason below and click on the submit button. This will alert our moderators to take actions